This story is completely off and hilariously dramatic. First of all it is dungeness, not dungeon. Second of all, cumberland island is owned by the national park service, you have to go to St Marys GA to get there by ferry. You can camp and see the wild horses, and do all the camping stuff. The house was built by I think the rockefellers, maybe the vanderbilts. It was one of those well known ultra rich families from the turn of the century. They abandoned it because they didnt want to pay the newly installed property taxes. The house had been abandoned for years when it did burn down sometime in the fifties. Nobody died in the fire, now the house is just a shell that you can look at when you visit the island. Makes me wonder who the person was who wrote this.

i used to live next to it, ive heard it before.

wow thats amazing but very scary

complete bullshit when I read the “found his body again” thing

i want to know the real truth stil trying to find a really haunted house! so far errything i found gets disqpproved!

Thomas and Lucy Carnegie’s Dungeness mansion on Cumberland Island burned in 1959.

This is crazy. but I don’t believe it, but if its true then thats crazy

This is not a true story. I live in St. Marys,Ga. which is the gateway to Cumberland Island.

HERE IS THE TRUE STORY!!! The true owner’s of the house were makers of an elixer that had made them millions of dollars. Their family name was “Spunkworthy”, an old welsh family. Their porduct was called “Ye old Spunkworthy’s Wack Off Cream”. and then their house burned down. My friend, Abu Saeed, says so.

I don’t believe it at all.

very scary at the “burned a second time” thing. i beleive. i beleive it could be scarier. loved it!!

thats kool

JESSICA is a LIAR. It is on the State Park and she NEVER lived “next to it”…The state would NOT let anyone live next to a burnt down home that was on state owned land.

Maybe she meant to tell everyone that she got some **** next to it and suck some guy off in a tent (and their 4 friends too.) But one thing is for sure, SHE DID NOT LIVE THERE so don’t believe her.

Actually there are people that DO live next to Dungeoness at a place called The Grange.

This house sounds wickedly awesome! If I was older I would totally buy it!

Shiela Curbs
keely456@hotmail.com

Hi. I do not believe this for the simple fact that , that could NEVER happen. And for anoher reason, all ghosts are are demonds and if youre a christian you know what I’m talking about. Im only 13 and i even know that. That’s just sad!!!!!

I do believe the part where some people have said that the house did burn down once and that the people may have been rich. Though that **** about the family eating dinner and all these ghost. Come on.

Dungeness is a reaaly nice place to go, but no ghosts.
The mansion did burn down they tried to rebuild what damage had been donebut it caught fire again. They say the carnigie family was cursed kinda like the kennedy curse no big deal

This is not true. I’ve visited Cumberland Island for probably the last ten years, and there is no such haunting. Aside from that, that is NOT what really happened to that mansion.

The house was built as a vacation home by the Carnegie family. For what it’s worth, nobody died in the fire. The only one in the house was the butler, and he escaped. Besides, you’re forbidden to try to even GET into the house, it’s so old and ramshackle. And it IS Dungeness, not Dungeon.